• Learn More
  • Forgot your password?
  • Questions? Call us at 800-207-8001
Click here to find out more!
Wednesday, May 16, 2012
  • HOME
  • WHITE HOUSE
  • POLITICS
  • CONGRESS
  • DOMESTIC POLICY
  • NATIONAL SECURITY
  • TECH
  • COLUMNS
    • Political Connections by Ronald Brownstein
    • The Cook Report by Charlie Cook
    • Off to the Races by Charlie Cook
    • All Powers by Major Garrett
    • On The Trail by Reid Wilson
    • Against the Grain by Josh Kraushaar
    • Common Sense by Matthew Dowd
    • Gwen's Take by Gwen Ifill
    • Vantage Point
  • BLOGS
    • 2012 Decoded
    • On Call
    • Tech Daily Dose
    • Influence Alley
    • Expert Blogs
  • POLLS
    • Politics Insiders
    • Congress Insiders
    • Energy Insiders
    • National Security Insiders
    • Congressional Connection
  • EVENTS

2012 Decoded Blog

To the Moon, Newt!

By Michael Hirsh
January 26, 2012 | 9:57 PM
  • Leave a Comment

After tonight's debate, I'd say Newt Gingrich has a better chance of being elected governor of America's 51st state--the Moon, presumably--than he does of getting to the White House.

It wasn't just that a tanned and confident Mitt Romney got the better of every exchange with Newt, at a time when Romney had begun surging ahead in the polls. (OMG, that's far too journalistically polite: he tore him to pieces!) Or that an inordinate amount of time was spent on Gingrich's loony idea of setting up a moon colony in the midst of the worst economic crisis since the Great Depression, reminding one and all of a trait that Gingrich was boasting about earlier today but which he didn't seem eager to bring up again: his "grandiosity."

The main problem for Gingrich was the complete absence of the fiery, base-rallying Newt that got him here in the first place.

Gingrich sounded peevish and defensive the whole night and barely landed a punch on Romney as the latter floated like a butterfly and stung like a bee. Whether the subject was Romney's taxes, his conservatism or even Romneycare--all badly tender spots for Mitt in past debates--Gingrich passed up chances to attack. (Rick Santorum, by contrast, was brutally effective once again in making the case that in an Obama-vs.-Romney race, Mitt would not be able to sufficiently distinguish himself as an alternative, that the president could simply turn to Mitt and say, "You say your plan worked in Massachusetts. So why not for the country?")

Romney's best line, perhaps, came over the lunar -- and loony -- portion of the debate. If one of his subordinates proposed spending hundreds of billions of dollars on a moon colony in the midst of all the needs "down here," Romney said, "I'd fire him." Gingrich mainly smiled a lot, shifted uncomfortably, whined about tough Romney ads (as he once did in Iowa before getting trounced there), and trotted out his familiar "repeal, repeal, repeal" spiel.

Gingrich's few counterattacks were feeble, barely noticed and easily parried. He often didn't make sense at all. When asked about his attacks on Romney's taxes and wealth, he responded that he was happy to say that on TV in an interview, but not in a national debate. Huh? When he sought to sully Romney over his investment links to Goldman Sachs and its foreclosures, Romney's retort that his investments were "blind trusts," while Newt's were not, went unanswered.

Maybe the best evidence that Romney sees himself as back on top was that, midway through the debate, he became the first one to attack Obama's State of the Union speech on Tuesday, saying if he's elected all those "promises" will be kept. His closing peroration--why he's the one person to be beat Obama--at least had a clear theme: to fix Washington, you've got to bring someone in "who's been on the outside."

Gingrich has had an extraordinary yo-yo-like spell as candidate--and he looks like he may be down at the end of his string once again. For good this time?


View All Decoded Posts by Michael Hirsh
Join the Discussion

The National Journal Group has the right (but not the obligation) to monitor the comments and to remove any materials it deems inappropriate.

Comments powered by Disqus
Follow National Journal
  • NationalJournal on Twitter
  • NationalJournal on Facebook
  • NationalJournal on Tumblr
  • NationalJournal's RSS Feeds
  • NationalJournal on iPhone and iPad
Search This Blog

Decoded Contributors

Tim Alberta

Tim Alberta

Editor, Hotline Last Call!

Decoded Posts | All Stories

Follow @HotlineAlberta

Ronald Brownstein

Ronald Brownstein

Editorial Director

Decoded Posts | All Stories


George E. Condon Jr.

George E. Condon Jr.

Staff Writer, White House

Decoded Posts | All Stories

Follow @georgecondon

Matthew Cooper

Matthew Cooper

Editor, National Journal Daily

Decoded Posts | All Stories

Follow @mattizcoop

John Aloysius Farrell

John Aloysius Farrell

Congressional Correspondent

Decoded Posts | All Stories

Follow @jaloysius

Ron Fournier

Ron Fournier

Editor-in-Chief

Decoded Posts | All Stories

Follow @ron_fournier

Chris Frates

Chris Frates

Lobbying Correspondent

Decoded Posts | All Stories

Follow @frates

Major Garrett

Major Garrett

Congress Correspondent

Decoded Posts | All Stories

Follow @MajoratNJ

Michael Hirsh

Michael Hirsh

Chief Correspondent

Decoded Posts | All Stories

Follow @michaelphirsh

Jackie Koszczuk

Jackie Koszczuk

Editor, The Almanac of American Politics

Decoded Posts | All Stories


Josh Kraushaar

Josh Kraushaar

Executive Editor, The Hotline

Decoded Posts | All Stories

Follow @HotlineJosh

Jill Lawrence

Jill Lawrence

Managing Editor, Politics

Decoded Posts | All Stories

Follow @JillDLawrence

James Oliphant

James Oliphant

Deputy Magazine Editor

Decoded Posts | All Stories

Follow @JamesOliphant

Beth Reinhard

Beth Reinhard

Political Correspondent

Decoded Posts | All Storie

Follow @bethreinhard

Alex Roarty

Alex Roarty

Staff Writer, Politics

Decoded posts | All Stories

Follow @Alex_Roarty

Reid Wilson

Reid Wilson

Editor-In-Chief, The Hotline

Decoded Posts | All Stories

Follow @HotlineReid

Archives

Monthly Archives

  • May 2012
  • April 2012
  • March 2012
  • February 2012
  • January 2012
  • December 2011
  • November 2011
  • October 2011
  • September 2011

Categories

  • 1994 (3)
  • 2008 presidential election (5)
  • 2012 (112)
  • Abortion (10)
  • Barack Obama (138)
  • California Primary (2)
  • Campaign Ads (10)
  • Campaign Finance (14)
  • Consumer Confidence
  • Contract With America (2)
  • Debates (52)
  • Delegates (1)
  • Economy (30)
  • Edward Kennedy (2)
  • Electoral College (1)
  • Florida (1)
  • Foreign Policy (5)
  • Gas price (1)
  • Green jobs (1)
  • Health Care (12)
  • Herman Cain (51)
  • Hillary Clinton (5)
  • House Races (2)
  • Immigration (7)
  • Iowa (60)
  • Joe Biden (4)
  • Michele Bachmann (27)
  • Mitt Romney (250)
  • New Hampshire (43)
  • Newt Gingrich (141)
  • Ohio (3)
  • Polls (63)
  • Rick Perry (66)
  • Rick Santorum (103)
  • Ron Paul (46)
  • Ronald Reagan (2)
  • Sarah Palin (13)
  • Senate Races (2)
  • Solyndra (1)
  • South Carolina (54)
  • Speaker John Boehner (2)
  • Super Tuesday (10)
  • Tax Reform (7)
  • Tea Party (20)
  • Unemployment (9)
  • Virginia (4)
  • Women (3)
  • delegates (1)

Recent Posts

  • Biden Plays Attack Dog on Bain
  • Romney's Targeted Deficit Messaging
  • New Presidential Polls Puncture Conventional Wisdom
  • In Commencement Speech Face-Off, Obama The Winner
  • Obama At Barnard: A Speech for November, Not the Ages
  • Romney Gets Facts Wrong on Gay Adoption
  • Bain Capital: Obama's Great White, Blue-Collar Hope
  • Political Hardball on Mother's Day: Why Not?
  • Why Liberty Won't Host Romney's 'Sister Souljah' Moment
  • Minorities and Gay Marriage: It's Evolving

NationalJournal Magazine | NationalJournal Daily | Hotline | Almanac | NationalJournal Live
About | Contact Us | Staff Bios | Jobs | Reprints & Back Issues | Advertise | Privacy Policy | Terms of Service
Atlantic Media Company | Government Executive | The Atlantic
Copyright © 2012 by National Journal Group Inc.
Powered by the Parse.ly Publisher Platform (P3).