• Learn More
  • Forgot your password?
  • Questions? Call us at 800-207-8001
Click here to find out more!
Wednesday, May 16, 2012
  • HOME
  • WHITE HOUSE
  • POLITICS
  • CONGRESS
  • DOMESTIC POLICY
  • NATIONAL SECURITY
  • TECH
  • COLUMNS
    • Political Connections by Ronald Brownstein
    • The Cook Report by Charlie Cook
    • Off to the Races by Charlie Cook
    • All Powers by Major Garrett
    • On The Trail by Reid Wilson
    • Against the Grain by Josh Kraushaar
    • Common Sense by Matthew Dowd
    • Gwen's Take by Gwen Ifill
    • Vantage Point
  • BLOGS
    • 2012 Decoded
    • On Call
    • Tech Daily Dose
    • Influence Alley
    • Expert Blogs
  • POLLS
    • Politics Insiders
    • Congress Insiders
    • Energy Insiders
    • National Security Insiders
    • Congressional Connection
  • EVENTS

2012 Decoded Blog

Immigration

« House Races | 2012 Decoded Home | Archives | Iowa »
Jackie Koszczuk

Obama and Romney -- and Their Tin Ears

By Jackie Koszczuk
March 6, 2012 | 7:51 PM
  • Leave a Comment
The typically fast-on-his-feet president showed on Tuesday that he can have as large a tin ear as Mitt Romney at times, which has to be reassuring for the likely Republican challenger, who struggles with the extemporaneous aspects of political life.

In response to a question at a White House press conference about whether he purposely wanted gas prices to go up to wean Americans off fossil fuels, Obama offered an answer from his political playbook -- before recovering and offering a second response from the "Message: I care" playbook.

Read More »

Beth Reinhard

Romney Allies on Both Sides of Immigration Debate

By Beth Reinhard
February 6, 2012 | 8:24 PM
  • Leave a Comment
Immigration advocates are raising hackles over today's endorsement of Mitt Romney by former California Gov. Pete Wilson. Wilson, of course, championed California's Proposition 187, which would have barred illegal immigrants from public schools and other government services. The referendum, which passed but was struck down in court, caused a sweeping anti-GOP backlash among Hispanics. "Didn't any of (Romney's) so-called smart operatives tell him that Pete Wilson has lower approval ratings than the devil himself?'' demanded a hyperbolic Frank Sharry, executive director of America's Voice.

The group pointed out in its e-mail blast today that Romnney's backers also include Kris Kobach, the Kansas Secretary of State who helped write the controversial law cracking down on illegal immigrants in Arizona, and Rep. Lamar Smith of Texas, another immigration hardliner.

But to be fair, Romney's supporters also include some of the Republican party's few and most prominent backers of a pathway to citizenship: Arizona Sen. John McCain, former Florida Sen. Mel Martinez, former U.S. Commerce Secretary Carlos Gutierrez and U.S. Reps. Ileana Ros-Lehntinen and Mario Diaz-Balart of Florida.

In conclusion, sometimes it's tricky to assign motives to a candidate based on their friends. What is clear, however, is Romney's own words and policies, which have a lot more common with the hardliners than the reformers and could thwart Hispanic outreach if he is the GOP nominee.


Ronald Brownstein

Why Immigration is Fizzling in Florida for Gingrich

By Ronald Brownstein
January 28, 2012 | 12:59 PM
  • Leave a Comment

MIAMI -- When Newt Gingrich pounded Mitt Romney's immigration policy as inhumane and unrealistic at last Thursday night's GOP debate, the sound of silence was deafening at the debate-watching party of a prominent Republican Hispanic group here.


Read More »

Ronald Brownstein

Debate Takeaways: Gingrich Loses Groove, Romney Gains Ground

By Ronald Brownstein
January 26, 2012 | 10:51 PM
  • Leave a Comment
MIAMI -- The takeaways took to the road for the latest Republican presidential debate. We watched along with a large crowd at the Hispanic Leadership Network, a Republican Hispanic group meeting here this week that co-sponsored the session. The crowd started raucous and engaged, but dwindled over the course of the two hours as the debate drifted in its final stages. But before the debate lost momentum, it left some clear impressions. Here are five:

Read More »

Ron Fournier

"Angry Newt" Takes the Night Off

By Ron Fournier
January 23, 2012 | 10:35 PM
  • Leave a Comment

"Angry Newt" took the night off. In a striking role reversal, Newt Gingrich looked more like a firefly than a firebrand in a high-stakes debate Monday night, while rival Mitt Romney called the surging former House Speaker a disgraced, influence-peddling, Washington insider.

Somebody must have awakened the cool-and-nonchalant Romney out of his debate slumber and told him the GOP nomination was slipping away. Gingrich stunned the political world -- and frightened much of the GOP establishment -- with a landslide victory in South Carolina on Saturday night that erased Romney's lead in national and Florida polls.

Read More »

Tags: 

Debate, Florida, National Journal, NBC, Paul, Romney, Santorum
Decoded Logo

What Romney Really Thinks On Immigration

By Staff Reporter
<-- img src="http://decoded.nationaljournal.com/gr/superblog.png" class="columnist-head" alt="Decoded Logo" -->
November 29, 2011 | 5:01 PM
  • Leave a Comment
Getting down to brass tacks: just what does Gov. Mitt Romney want to do with the 12 million+ undocumented immigrants inside the United States?  This is an important question for the substance of the GOP primary debate, but it's also one that the Romney campaign needs to have answered -- that is -- it behooves them to leave open any room for misinterpretation. 

Romney's campaign points to a Meet the Press appearance from 2007 as the gold standard for his answer, an answer they deem to be consistent with past views:


GOV. ROMNEY: Now let's, now let's look at those very carefully, OK, and you're, you're a careful reader. In the interview with The Boston Globe, I described all three programs that were out there, described what they were, acknowledged that they were not technically an amnesty program, but I indicated in that same interview that I had not formulated my own proposal and that I was endorsing none of those three programs. I did not support any of them. I called them reasonable. They are reasonable efforts to, to look at the problem. But I said I did not support--and I said specifically in that interview I have not formulated my own policy and have not determined which I would support. And, of course, the Cornyn proposal required all of the immigrants to go home. The McCain proposal required most of them to go home, but let some stay. And the Bush proposal I, frankly, don't recall in that much detail. But they had very different proposals. My own view is consistent with what you saw in the Lowell Sun, that those people who had come here illegally and are in this country--the 12 million or so that are here illegally--should be able to stay sign up for permanent residency or citizenship, but they should not be given a special pathway, a special guarantee that all of them get to say here for the rest of their lives merely by virtue of having come here illegally. And that, I think, is the great flaw in the final bill that came forward from the Senate.


MR. RUSSERT: But they shouldn't have to go home?


GOV. ROMNEY: Well, whether they go home--they should go home eventually. There's a set per--in my view they should be--they should have a set period during which period they, they sign up for application for permanent residency or, or for citizenship. But there's a set period where upon they should return home. And if they've been approved for citizenship or for a permanent residency, well, thy would be a different matter. But for the great majority, they'll be going home.


MR. RUSSERT: The children they had born here are U.S. citizens, so do the children stay here and the parents go home?


GOV. ROMNEY: Well, that's a choice, of course, the parents would, would make. But my view is that those 12 million who've come here illegally should be given the opportunity to sign up to stay here, but they should not be given any advantage in becoming a permanent resident or citizen by virtue of simply coming here illegally. And likewise, if they've brought a child to this country or they've had a child in this country, that's, that's wonderful that they're growing their families, but that doesn't mean that they all get to stay here indefinitely. We're fundamentally a nation of laws.


So, from this, we can discern that Romney wouldn't order the Border Patrol to round up all of them and throw them out immediately.

He recognizes that there may be cases where it makes sense, from a variety of perspectives, to allow some who registers with the government to stay in the US for a certain period of time.

He favors the establishment of a process that would speed legal immigration to the US...one that would incorporate a registration process for undocumented immigrants.

In that process, the illegal immigrants would not be given any preferential treatment for coming here illegally. It would take LONGER for their citizenship claims to process.

At some point, every undocumented immigrant would have to return home for a period of time. The factors that would determine this would presumably vary by immigrant.

It would not make a difference, according to Romney, whether the immigrant in question had children in the United States; it would be their choice whether to take the child back to their country of origin, but they would not have a choice as to whether to leave.

Another implication is that Romney would create a hybrid status for undocumented immigrants who register...they would not be resident aliens, per se, nor would they be officially undocumented...while they were in the U.S., and while they had registered, some of them (presumably) would be able to continue working for a while until they were forced to return home as part of the citizenship process.   

A year earlier, Romney was quoted as saying that "[w]e need to begin a process of registering those people, some being returned, and some beginning the process of applying for citizenship and establishing legal status."   This is not inconsistent with the views he stated in 2007; what has shifted over time is his rhetoric and his emphasis.  He doesn't favor mass deportations, but he does not favor what he calls a special advantage for those who violated the law to become citizens.  

Left unanswered, though, is what process Romney favors:  once you agree to let some illegal immigrants stay in the U.S. after you know they are illegal, you are granting them, to some degree, temporary amnesty from the law, which would otherwise see them deported.  Romney could never call this amnesty, of course, because that word has become so pregnant with meaning among conservatives.  

The difference between Romney and Gingrich appears to be a difference in degree:  under Romney, undocumented aliens would have to return home for a period of time -- details of this complex process TBD.  Under Gingrich, many, especially those with families, would not be forced to leave the United States.  They wouldn't become citizens, but neither would they find themselves jailed.  
Jackie Koszczuk

Arpaio Rides to Perry's Rescue on Immigration

By Jackie Koszczuk
November 29, 2011 | 10:33 AM
  • Leave a Comment

Texas Gov. Rick Perry took a major step this morning toward inoculating his campaign against the soft-on-illegal-immigration rap when he scooped up the endorsement of Maricopa County Sheriff Joe Arpaio, the Arizona lawman who has become the most recognizable symbol of transcendent voter frustration with runaway illegal immigration.

"The federal government has failed on border crime and border enforcement, and no candidate for president has done more to secure the border than Governor Rick Perry. I have been watching Governor Perry and Texas closely and know his border surge operations with state, local and federal law enforcement officials have helped shut down the illegal trafficking of weapons, drugs and people," Arpaio said in a statement today distributed by the Perry campaign.

Campaigning in New Hampshire this morning, Perry also used the occasion to pledge that as president, he will detain and deport apprehended illegal immigrants through expedited hearings, a tougher stance than he had before the issue became an ankle chain on his campaign.
 

Read More »

Tags: 

border security, endorsement, FBI, illegal immigrants, Joe Arpaio, tuition
« House Races | 2012 Decoded Home | Archives | Iowa »
Follow National Journal
  • NationalJournal on Twitter
  • NationalJournal on Facebook
  • NationalJournal on Tumblr
  • NationalJournal's RSS Feeds
  • NationalJournal on iPhone and iPad
Search This Blog

Decoded Contributors

Tim Alberta

Tim Alberta

Editor, Hotline Last Call!

Decoded Posts | All Stories

Follow @HotlineAlberta

Ronald Brownstein

Ronald Brownstein

Editorial Director

Decoded Posts | All Stories


George E. Condon Jr.

George E. Condon Jr.

Staff Writer, White House

Decoded Posts | All Stories

Follow @georgecondon

Matthew Cooper

Matthew Cooper

Editor, National Journal Daily

Decoded Posts | All Stories

Follow @mattizcoop

John Aloysius Farrell

John Aloysius Farrell

Congressional Correspondent

Decoded Posts | All Stories

Follow @jaloysius

Ron Fournier

Ron Fournier

Editor-in-Chief

Decoded Posts | All Stories

Follow @ron_fournier

Chris Frates

Chris Frates

Lobbying Correspondent

Decoded Posts | All Stories

Follow @frates

Major Garrett

Major Garrett

Congress Correspondent

Decoded Posts | All Stories

Follow @MajoratNJ

Michael Hirsh

Michael Hirsh

Chief Correspondent

Decoded Posts | All Stories

Follow @michaelphirsh

Jackie Koszczuk

Jackie Koszczuk

Editor, The Almanac of American Politics

Decoded Posts | All Stories


Josh Kraushaar

Josh Kraushaar

Executive Editor, The Hotline

Decoded Posts | All Stories

Follow @HotlineJosh

Jill Lawrence

Jill Lawrence

Managing Editor, Politics

Decoded Posts | All Stories

Follow @JillDLawrence

James Oliphant

James Oliphant

Deputy Magazine Editor

Decoded Posts | All Stories

Follow @JamesOliphant

Beth Reinhard

Beth Reinhard

Political Correspondent

Decoded Posts | All Storie

Follow @bethreinhard

Alex Roarty

Alex Roarty

Staff Writer, Politics

Decoded posts | All Stories

Follow @Alex_Roarty

Reid Wilson

Reid Wilson

Editor-In-Chief, The Hotline

Decoded Posts | All Stories

Follow @HotlineReid

Archives

Monthly Archives

  • May 2012
  • April 2012
  • March 2012
  • February 2012
  • January 2012
  • December 2011
  • November 2011
  • October 2011
  • September 2011

Categories

  • 1994 (3)
  • 2008 presidential election (5)
  • 2012 (112)
  • Abortion (10)
  • Barack Obama (138)
  • California Primary (2)
  • Campaign Ads (10)
  • Campaign Finance (14)
  • Consumer Confidence
  • Contract With America (2)
  • Debates (52)
  • Delegates (1)
  • Economy (30)
  • Edward Kennedy (2)
  • Electoral College (1)
  • Florida (1)
  • Foreign Policy (5)
  • Gas price (1)
  • Green jobs (1)
  • Health Care (12)
  • Herman Cain (51)
  • Hillary Clinton (5)
  • House Races (2)
  • Immigration (7)
  • Iowa (60)
  • Joe Biden (4)
  • Michele Bachmann (27)
  • Mitt Romney (250)
  • New Hampshire (43)
  • Newt Gingrich (141)
  • Ohio (3)
  • Polls (63)
  • Rick Perry (66)
  • Rick Santorum (103)
  • Ron Paul (46)
  • Ronald Reagan (2)
  • Sarah Palin (13)
  • Senate Races (2)
  • Solyndra (1)
  • South Carolina (54)
  • Speaker John Boehner (2)
  • Super Tuesday (10)
  • Tax Reform (7)
  • Tea Party (20)
  • Unemployment (9)
  • Virginia (4)
  • Women (3)
  • delegates (1)

Recent Posts

  • Biden Plays Attack Dog on Bain
  • Romney's Targeted Deficit Messaging
  • New Presidential Polls Puncture Conventional Wisdom
  • In Commencement Speech Face-Off, Obama The Winner
  • Obama At Barnard: A Speech for November, Not the Ages
  • Romney Gets Facts Wrong on Gay Adoption
  • Bain Capital: Obama's Great White, Blue-Collar Hope
  • Political Hardball on Mother's Day: Why Not?
  • Why Liberty Won't Host Romney's 'Sister Souljah' Moment
  • Minorities and Gay Marriage: It's Evolving

NationalJournal Magazine | NationalJournal Daily | Hotline | Almanac | NationalJournal Live
About | Contact Us | Staff Bios | Jobs | Reprints & Back Issues | Advertise | Privacy Policy | Terms of Service
Atlantic Media Company | Government Executive | The Atlantic
Copyright © 2012 by National Journal Group Inc.
Powered by the Parse.ly Publisher Platform (P3).